JJ Abrams is Star Wars’s New Hope

Odds are you’ve heard that JJ Abrams of Star Trek fame has been selected to direct the new Star Wars movies under the Disney brand. What do I think?

It’s great news. Say what you will about Star Trek, but it was a great movie and a very accessible film. Sure, it messed with the canon, but it messed mostly with the canon from the original series — who cares? Star Trek was languishing with so many bad movies being made from it. Add in the failure of Enterprise to be watched and it was pretty clear someone needed to come in and make it good again. Abrams was the man for that job.

JJ was, allegedly, already approached for the Star Wars movies. He declined originally because, again, allegedly, he didn’t want to touch something so sacred. That’s right — JJ Abrams, a man painted as a money-hungry control freak with a penchant for lens flares was scared of messing up Star Wars. That’s a good sign. And they have a skilled writer in Michael Arndt, so unless Abrams insists on messing with the script too badly, we have nothing to worry about.

A final point, of course, is Disney’s past insistence on the new films not following the canon. Obviously we all want a Thrawn trilogy of films but it’s not going to happen — Zahn‘s magnum opus is going to be left sitting in a parallel universe. That’s something we kind of have to live with. What this means is that even if the new movie(s) are horrible, we can still take solace in the fact that the books haven’t been desecrated.

I would be shocked if Abrams and Arndt could screw this up. They are both big names, they’re both riding off big successes, they’re both nerds, and they both know what’s at stake. They could single-handedly revive a dying franchise that’s only hanging on by the occasional new novel and/or tabletop RPG. Besides — the New trilogy was god awful. How could they do worse?


3 Comments on “JJ Abrams is Star Wars’s New Hope”

  1. Anth says:

    I love both Star Trek and Star Wars respectively but I’m more of a ST fan than a SW fan. I thoroughly enjoyed the 2009 Star Trek film and reinvented The Original Series for the better IMHO. I’m pretty excited that he’s going to be sitting in the director’s chair for the first Star Wars film but wondering if he’ll have a future still in the Star Trek franchise at least in a consulting role – I’d hate it that the whole creative team Orci, Kurtzman and Lindelof to all move over to Star Wars. It’d make me a very sad boy.

    I think he’ll do a great job especially if Timothy Zahn is brought on as the writer…. Wishful thinking? OR AWESOME THINKING?!

    • James says:

      Agreed. I hope Abrams gets to work with both, but he is in the ultimate fanboy dilemma. Mixing the dark side — Star Trek — with the light is a recipe for disaster. We’ll see what he does!

      Zahn would make an interesting choice as a writer, but having read all his books I’m sorry to say there is a lot of predictability. If they did the Thrawn trilogy however I would die a happy man.

      • Anth says:

        I think he’s more of a Star Wars fan than a Star Trek one in my observations of his ongoing themes in science fiction. Then again that’s a whole philosophical discussion on another plain.

        That’s my wishful thinking is that they’d ask Timothy Zahn to write a screenplay based on that trilogy but I’m not sure that’ll happen. I think what will happen is JJ will only be directing one of the sequel episodes and the others will go to different directors entirely.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s